智庫政策影響力評(píng)價(jià)中的“唯批示論”迷思——基于政策過程理論視角的研究

摘要： 文章以智庫政策影響力概念梳理為基礎(chǔ),結(jié)合大量實(shí)證案例,揭示了我國智庫政策影響力評(píng)價(jià)中普遍存在"唯批示論"現(xiàn)象。基于政策過程理論,文章通過對(duì)CTTI(中國智庫索引)中的內(nèi)參和批示進(jìn)行文獻(xiàn)計(jì)量,分析了該現(xiàn)象帶來的主要問題,并初步探討了破除智庫評(píng)價(jià)體系"唯批示論"的方法,以期為新時(shí)代中國特色新型智庫評(píng)價(jià)及建設(shè)提供參考。
Based on the concept of think tank policy influence and a large number of empirical cases, this paper reveals that the phenomenon of "instruction-centric" is prevalent in the evaluation of think tank policy influence in China.Based on the theory of policy process, this paper makes a bibliometric analysis of the internal references and instructions in the "China Think Tank Index", analyses the main problems brought about by this phenomenon, and preliminarily explores the method of breaking the "instruction-centric" method in the evaluation system of think tanks, with a view to providing reference for the evaluation and construction of new think tanks with Chinese characteristics in the new era.